Jump to content


Photo

German Unification - Higher History


  • Please log in to reply
1 reply to this topic

#1 Mikey

Mikey
  • Student
  • 1 posts

Posted 30 April 2011 - 06:41 PM

Hey, a friend has recommended this website to me to get help on the following question for Higher history:

"Why was unification achieved in Germany by 1871?"

My teacher has given me a list of subjects to discuss in this essay:
The role of Bismarck
The decline of Austria
Prussian military strength
Prussian economic strength
The attitude of other states
The actions of Napoleon

From my textbook I have learned many facts that I can include about these subjects, but I do not understand how I can link them to how Germany was unified by 1871. Without this information, I cannot answer what the question is asking. Can someone please briefly expalin how each of these subjects helped Germany to unify? Thank you very much, this will be incredibly helpful to me :)

#2 MrJohnDClare

MrJohnDClare
  • Moderating Teacher & Admin
  • 5,342 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:County Durham

Posted 01 May 2011 - 09:46 AM

Hi Mikey!
Please forgive me, but your post made me smile!

The way you answer a simple causation essay like this one at A-level is 'analytically'.
That means that you construct a list of causes, and then you give a paragraph to each one, remembering to PELE every paragraph - making the Point, then Explaining how it caused the thing in the title, whilst making sure you Link each cause to the other causes to construct an integrated 'web' of causation, and citing Evidence which supports your claims and suggestions.

Now, I notice that your teacher has given you the list of points, and if I now tell you all the explanations, where - I wondered - is your part in this essay!
;)
Sorry - I'm just being cheeky!

Speaking more seriously, your teacher HAS given you the list of points, and your job now is to construct the explanations.
You will have to do this yourself, but I will give you some clues.
1. The role of Bismarck - look at the policies he pursued leading up to unification, and think HOW each one helped to bring unification nearer.
2. The decline of Austria - the ruler of Austria was Holy Roman Emperor, and therefore had a great political influence over the tiny German states. How would he feel about unification under Prussia, and why did the declining power of Austria therefore help unfiiation?
3. Prussian military strength - what part did this play in the process of unification and when (especially, there is a specific event I am thinking of)
4. Prussian economic strength - again, there is a specific historical event, usually cited as the beginning of the unification process, which you need to mention)
5. The attitude of other states - France was rabidly anti-unification, and therefore needed to be militarily defeated, but what about the others? What would have happened if they had ALL been rabidly anti-unification. What bought them off?
6. The actions of Napoleon - see below.

Now remember also that at A-level you are not looking at mono-causal explanations. You need, for each point, to be able to explain a number of ways in which each point caused the event in question.

An example would be for Napoleon.
Napoleon helped to stimulate unification in many ways.
a. Firstly, he united the Germans in hatred to the French domination!
b. He also united Germany politically, doing away with the hundreds of tiny states, and lumping them together into larger units; Napoleon was the end, essentially, of the Holy Roman Empire.
c. Historians also see a link between the principles of the French Revolution, and the growth of 'nationalism', and they therefore date the German unification movement back to then.
d. Napoleon permanently dinted the power of Austria but Prussia came out of the Napoloenic wars stronger than before.

Can you see how you can therefore offer, for Napoleon, a multi-causal explanation of how he helped unification?


Finally, don't forget to end with a conclusion which:
1. draws all the 'link' points together and makes explicit the causal 'web' whereby all the 'points' worked together to cause unification.
2. where valid, this is a good time to mention individual historians, and cast a nod to historiography.


Hope this helps, and please forgive my slight mocking at the start.
:)




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users