Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Enquiry Skills Confusion - Sg.
History Help Forum > Topics > 14-16 year olds' help and guidance
BrokenStrings
Hello.
This is my first post, so I apologise in advance for any errors. unsure.gif

Well, basically I'm completely bamboozled with the whole idea of Enquiry Skills. I'm in third year doing standard grade and just about to sit a third year exam.
When I was attempting revision, I realised I didn't quite grasp the idea of the enquiry skills and that's how I came across this site.. looking for help.
So I was browsing through some previous posts and I found some quite useful stuff. BUT. the techniques i've found seem to confuse me more because I'm not quite sure where to use them.

I got some revision stuff from my teacher and all the enquiry skills stuff is based on an "Issue For Investigating" and before I came on this site, I didn't realise there are different types of questions. The ones i have all seem to have the same structure.. like "How useful are SOURCES A and B as evidence of .. " etc. then "What evidence in the sources supports/suggests other reasons for .. " etc. then the last one asks for a balanced conclusion. What type of enquiry skills is this?

I'm not sure if I'm making much sense wacko.gif .. but any ideas?

Thanks.
MrJohnDClare
Quite frankly, this issue is very badly addressed on the internet, and I'm not surprised you're a bit at sea with it.
There is much more help and structure for English GCSE students with sourcework (which is the same thing) than there is for Scottish students with 'Enquiry Skills'.

On the syllabus, it defines 'Enquiry SKills' as follows:
QUOTE
• evaluating sources with reference to their historical significance, the points of view
conveyed in them and to the relevant historical context
• selecting and organising


and it says this about what you have to know how to do to get the diffent levels:
QUOTE
6 8 Enquiry Skills – Extended Grade Related Criteria

Foundation Level (Grades 6 and 5)
Given a source or sources the candidate can:
• support a given evaluation by reference to features such as accuracy, authorship, purpose, contemporaneity, bias, exaggeration or consistency
• identify points of similarity and difference in simple sources
• identify and/or give a simple explanation of the points of view and/or actions conveyed in sources
• select and record from sources information appropriate to a given topic
• use information from sources to present findings in relation to a given topic.

General Level (Grades 4 and 3)
Given a source or sources, the candidate can:
• make an evaluation of the source(s) and support this by reference to features such as accuracy, authorship, purpose, contemporaneity, bias, exaggeration or consistency
• compare points of view conveyed in the source(s)
• identify and/or explain the points of view and/or actions conveyed in the source(s)
• set the source(s) in a wider historical context by reference to features such as purpose, timing and the significance of its (their) content
• select and organise information from sources appropriate to a given issue
• use sources together with recalled knowledge to suggest a conclusion to an issue.

Credit Level (Grades 2 and 1)
Given a source or source(s), the candidate can:
• make a balanced evaluation of the strengths and weaknesses of the source(s) and support this by reference to features such as accuracy, authorship, purpose, contemporaneity, bias, exaggeration or consistency
• compare points of view conveyed in the source(s)
• give a balanced explanation of the points of view and/or actions conveyed in the source(s)
• set the source(s) in a wider historical context with extended reference to features such as purpose, timing and the significance of its (their) content
• select and organise information from complex sources appropriate to a given issue
• use sources together with recalled knowledge to draw a well-supported and balanced conclusion to a given issue.



There is a webpage here, giving you a summary of the types of Enquiry SKills question you will meet at SG.
And this article seems particularly clear.
As far as I can glean, however, you are correct in thinking that the same kind of questions are asked every year, but that the exact style of question may change - you may need to look at the question and tell yourself: 'Ah yes - this is one of those questions'.

By far the best advice on these has been given on this forum by our own wonderful A Finemess, on this thread:
Enquiry Skills questions
You can also get some (rather shallow) further advice if you go to this BBC Bitesize page and do a search (<CTRL-F>)for 'Enquiry skills', and then a second search for 'source'.

One more thing you MUST do is to see your teacher, and to get him to let you look at some past papers - then you will be able to see the different kinds of question you might be asked.


Finally, at the risk of confusing you, I found this booklet while I was browsing the net. It appears to be for Modern Studies, but it has some good ideas.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.